News & Legal Commentary

The Legal Quandary of Contract Workers and Taxes

The Legal Quandary of Contract Workers and Taxes

byLecker & Associates | Contract Worker Rights , Employment Contracts

 Contract Workers and Taxes | Co-Authors: Jordan Reiner and Bram Lecker


The Legal Quandary of Contract Workers and Taxes

Thousands of workers provide services as contractor workers in Ontario. They span professions like hair dressers, naturopaths, sales representatives and software developers, to name a few. They are employed by small and mid-sized businesses, like beauty parlours and wellness clinics, as well as large institutions, like national banks. Until recently, their status remained ambiguous in Ontario. Were they employees, depenent contractors performing work like employees or self-employed independent contractors? Are they entitled to vacation pay and overtime? And who is responsible for federal source deductions, like Income Tax EI and CPP? Matters concerning contract workers and taxes remain a legal quandary.

In January this year, the Ontario government attempted to clean some of this up. Bill 148 brought sweeping reforms to the Employment Standards Act (ESA). Employers must now clearly classify their workers as employees, dependent contractors or independent contractors. Provincial laws protect dependent contractors just like employees. They are entitled to the same benefits, including vacation pay, overtime, health and disability benefits, etc.

However, the ESA remains in provincial jurisdiction. Your federal deductions and entitlements are governed by the Income Tax Act. Unlike the ESA, it does not yet recognize your dependent contractor status.

Federal Income Tax Act

The Income Tax Act stipulates the requirements for insurable and pensionable earnings. For standard employment relationships, the law holds your employer responsible for deducting taxes and source deductions, like EI and CPP, from your income. They must remit these in a timely manner to the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA). These contributions determine your benefit entitlements to Employment Insurance and the Canada Pension Plan.

If you work as an independent contractor, the law views your working relationship just like a business transaction. Accordingly, you invoice your clients for your services and collect/remit GST/HST, as applicable. The CRA allows you to claim deductions for business purposes, like rent, internet and mileage. The earnings of the business are not insurable or pensionable and you may opt out of the Employment Insurance Plan. However, as a self-employed individual, the CRA holds you responsible for source deductions  like income tax & CPP for money you draw to pay yourself.

Dependent contractors fall somewhere in-between. In fact, many dependent contractors only become aware of the tax quagmire when their employment ends. Although Ontario laws deem your status no different from employees, you may not be eligible for Employment Insurance. The CRA may incorrectly consider you a self-employed independent contractor, holding you responsible for source deductions and penalizing you with interest for not remitting your payroll taxes on time. Presently, dependent contractors must jump through a few hoops first, to shift this burden onto their employers.

Contract Workers and Taxes: Lyon Vs. Her Majesty the Queen

In 2016, we won a precedent setting case, Keenan v. Canac Kitchens, for dependent contractor clients. Our team of lawyers played a significant role in drawing the line that delineated dependent contractors from independent contractors. These standards formed the basis for provincial reforms enacted in Bill 148.

Recently, we embarked on a similar exercise with the Federal Income Tax Act through our case, Kearsten M. Lyon v. Her Majesty the Queen. It offers a classic example of the challenges many dependent contractors face. Ms. Lyon began working as a contractor with Kinetica Health Group in 2008. She performed clerical work as a receptionist and office administrator. Two years later, she upgraded her skills and assumed additional responsibilities as a Chiropractic and Physiotherapy Assistant and Certified Pilates Instructor.

From the onset, Lyon did not bill Kinetica any GST/HST.  The owner of Kinetica, Peter Tzakas, was a licenced chiropractor, exempted from collecting and remitting these taxes. He advised Lyon that, since her services to clients were performed under his licence, she was GST/HST exempt as well. This notion turned out to be false as Ms. Lyon discovered in 2016. She eventually learned that she should have collected GST/HST all along. Consequently, Ms. Lyon advised Mr. Tzakas that she would bill him for taxes, retroactively.

Employment Status Change

Soon after, Mr. Tzakas changed the employment relationship with Ms. Lyon, as well as other staff at the clinic. They mutually agreed to become employees of Kinetica, retroactive to January 1st, 2016. Mr. Tzakas made source deductions, including EI and CPP, and remitted them to the CRA. But this arrangement did not last long for Ms. Lyon. On June 18th, 2016, Mr. Tzakas terminated her employment. On paper, Ms. Lyon had only been an employee of Kinetica for a few months. She was ineligible for Employment Insurance and the CRA considered her an independent contractor, responsible for back taxes.

She therefore applied to the CRA to prove her status as an employee of Kinetica for the entire duration of her employment relationship. They agreed to assess her status from 2015 and 2016 and advised they would assess 2011 to 2014 only after the first decision was rendered. Initially, Ms. Lyon successfully established that she was an employee for 2015 and 2016. However, Mr. Tzakas appealed the decision and the CRA reversed it’s own ruling. Ms. Lyon’s case escalated to the Tax Court of Canada.

Tax Court of Canada (TCC)

The Income Tax Act is quite different from the ESA. It has no provision for recognizing employment status. Rather, Tax Courts examine the intent and nature of the working relationship to determine who carries responsibility for deducting and remitting taxes and source deductions to the CRA.

The process involves two steps. First, the court examines the subjective intent of each party in the work relationship. And secondly, they ascertain whether the terms of the relationship remain consistent with the intention. Through the trial, they review factors like degree of control, ownership of the tools, chance of profit and risk of loss, etc.

After a thorough examination of the facts, the TCC concluded that Ms. Lyon was indeed, an employee of Kinetica. They disregarded the expressed intentions of an independent contractor relationship because the objective factors did not support those intentions. In other words, the historical independent contractor relationship was irrelevant because all the facts pointed to a traditional employment relationship. The ruling held Kinetica responsible for the back taxes

Case Facts

The TCC ruling was influenced by the extent of control Mr. Tzakas held in this work relationship. For starters, he held full economic control. Ms. Lyon was neither a shareholder at Kinetica nor did she stand to earn a profit or risk a loss. She earned an hourly rate for her administrative and clerical tasks as well as Pilates, chiropractic and physiotherapy duties. The clinic provided almost all of Ms. Lyon’s clients, compensating her for the Pilates services with a percentage of the fees they charged the clients. The Court determined that this was akin to an employee earning income through commissions. It was not indicative of an independent contractor relationship.

Mr. Tzakas also maintained a large degree of control over her activities. For example, while Ms. Lyon set fees for her sessions, he insisted on being consulted and had final say in the changes she made to packages or rates. Mr. Tzakas required her to see his clients on Kinetica premises using his equipment and prevented her from seeing them elsewhere. Kinetica handled all client bookings for her Pilates sessions through their on-line scheduling system. They billed clients for her services using invoices with their logo. Mr. Tzakas expected Ms. Lyon to operate under the Kinetica brand, providing her with business cards that suggested she was a staff member. He also required her to fill out time sheets each week on forms that listed her as “staff”.

In the words of the Court, “to the outside world, Lyon would have been perceived as being an employee of Kinetica.” They determined that Ms. Lyon was not a contractor for 2015 and 2016 and held Kinetica responsible for the back taxes. The CRA will now use this ruling to assess her taxes for 2011 to 2014.

Signalling Dependent Contractors

This decision is important for many workers. If you have traditionally worked under contract, then your employer must classify you as either dependent or independent. The matter of contract workers and taxes remains complicated and federal laws have yet to catch up with dependent contractor status. If you are facing tax problems with the CRA and they have incorrectly classified you as an independent contractor, then give us a call. Our Toronto employment lawyers are not afraid to wade into this uncharted territory. We can examine your circumstances and advise you better than most.


If you enjoyed this article, please consider sharing it.

Testimonials from Employees Like You

Posted on Google Google
Joanne Bissonnette profile picture
Joanne Bissonnette
2026-11-12
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Joanne Bissonnette 25 September 2026 Awesome Team ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ "Thank you so much to Soniya Ponniah and Ashley Hussey at Lecker & Associates. You provided wonderful support, guidance, and clear communication throughout this employment law matter. Your exceptional legal counsel and strategic management led directly to a successful and highly agreeable resolution. I highly recommend your legal services. Thank you again!"
Posted on Google Google
cj ** profile picture
cj **
2026-11-09
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
It was a great experience for their service back in 2017. I had never used legal service for employment issues before in my life. I gave it a try and I found it very satisfied. You never know it until you try, They charged fee appropriately without more than they needed. Thank you Lecker!
Posted on Google Google
Eric Bibeau profile picture
Eric Bibeau
2026-11-03
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I can’t say enough good things about Lecker & Associates. From the first conversation, Matthew Fisher was clear, honest and strategic. He explained my options in plain language, set realistic expectations, and guided me to an outcome I’m very happy with. I always felt he was on my side and that my interests came first. Eslita Ramkishun was outstanding throughout. She was organized, quick to respond, and walked me through every document and next step, which made a stressful process feel manageable. What stood out most was how thoughtful and caring the whole team was. They treated me like a person, not a file. If you need a firm that combines sharp legal guidance with real compassion, I highly recommend Matthew, Eslita and the team at Lecker & Associates. — Eric Bibeau
Posted on Google Google
Gaz Kondaj profile picture
Gaz Kondaj
2026-10-29
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I cannot speak highly enough of Lecker & Associates and the exceptional legal representation and support I received from Kimberley, Ian, and Tina. From the very beginning, Kimberley demonstrated an outstanding level of professionalism, legal expertise, and strategic thinking. Her confidence, attention to detail, and thorough understanding of the legal process were instrumental in guiding the team toward a remarkable victory. Her ability to navigate complex challenges while remaining focused, composed, and determined truly sets her apart. Ian and Tina were equally exceptional, providing invaluable support, clear communication, and dedication throughout the entire process. Together, they demonstrated what a strong, knowledgeable, and committed legal team can accomplish. What impressed me most was not only the successful outcome, but also the integrity, professionalism, and genuine commitment they demonstrated every step of the way. It was reassuring to know that my matter was in such capable hands. A special thank you to Kimberley for her exceptional leadership, expertise, and determination in achieving such a fantastic result. I wholeheartedly recommend Lecker & Associates to anyone seeking outstanding legal representation. An exceptional team that delivers results and truly earns your trust!
Posted on Google Google
Jose Duran profile picture
Jose Duran
2026-10-18
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
This is the second time I have turned to Lecker & Associates for assistance with a work-related legal matter, and once again, the experience has exceeded my expectations. Counsel Jordan Reiner provided exceptional support throughout the process, demonstrating a thorough and thoughtful assessment of my situation, sound guidance grounded in experience, and a genuinely client-centered approach. He took the time to understand the circumstances, clearly explained my options, and provided the professional guidance and reassurance needed to navigate the matter with confidence. Thanks to his expertise, diligence, and commitment to achieving the best possible outcome, my legal matter was resolved successfully. It is reassuring to know that I can rely on a firm that combines legal expertise with a genuine commitment to its clients. I highly recommend Counsel Jordan Reiner and Lecker & Associates to anyone seeking knowledgeable, professional, and results-oriented legal representation, particularly in employment-related matters. Their consistent quality of service is the reason I have returned to the firm, and I would not hesitate to seek their assistance again.
Posted on Google Google
Barbara M. profile picture
Barbara M.
2026-10-09
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I had a great experience and outcome with the help of Nathan Whitteningham-Paralegal. He was professional and knowledgeable. He was always available to answer my many questions, explained my rights, and outlined the best approach to handle my situation with confidence. Though it felt like an eternity, Nathan was able to wrap up matters in quick order. I highly recommend his services.
Posted on Google Google
Yashraj Gandhi profile picture
Yashraj Gandhi
2026-10-08
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I had an excellent experience working with Jordan Reiner and Ashley Hussey on my case. They were professional, knowledgeable, responsive, and genuinely supportive throughout the process. I truly appreciate their dedication and the quality of service they provided. Highly recommended!
Posted on Google Google
xi li profile picture
xi li
2026-10-07
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I had a very positive experience with Lecker & Associates throughout my employment matter. Ashley Hussey and Ms. Ponniah were both professional, responsive, knowledgeable, and supportive throughout the process. They explained the process clearly, kept me informed, and handled my matter with care and professionalism. I truly appreciate their hard work and guidance, and I would recommend Lecker & Associates to anyone looking for professional assistance with an employment matter.
Posted on Google Google
Syrrel Cabiling profile picture
Syrrel Cabiling
2026-10-07
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I had the pleasure of being represented by Soniya regarding my employment matters. Soniya, Ashley, and Melissa were prompt, organized, and responsive throughout the process, ensuring that all of my questions and concerns were addressed. I truly appreciated their professionalism, guidance, and commitment to protecting my best interests. I would highly recommend their services.
Posted on Google Google
Uma Seetal profile picture
Uma Seetal
2026-10-03
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I’m extremely grateful for all the help and guidance I received with my employment matter. Matthew Fisher was incredibly knowledgeable, supportive, and genuinely dedicated to fighting for me. They took the time to explain everything clearly, answer all of my questions, and guide me through every step of the process. Eslita was excellent — very responsive, organized, and proactive with communication, which made everything feel smooth and well-managed. I truly appreciate the time, effort, and care that went into my case. I would absolutely recommend Matthew to anyone who needs someone knowledgeable and committed to fighting for their rights.

Breathe Easy, We’ve Got This

Reputation Matters