News & Legal Commentary

Bonus Pay

Bonus Pay

byLecker & Associates | Commission & Unpaid Wages , Employee Rights and Entitlements , Fired, Laid-off, or Forced out

Who Doesn’t Love Bonus Pay?

Bonus pay usually operates as a win-win in most employment relationships.  Astute employers use it to incentivize, offering employees a tangible reward for going over and beyond their job requirements. However, bonus pay can become a lightning rod for conflict when business conditions change.

Why Employers Deny Bonus Pay

Some employers withhold bonus pay to save money. A good case in point is Ontario’s recent overhaul in employment standards. Bill 148 has caused a sudden rise in the minimum wage with higher payroll costs. Arguments on the impact of these changes on the economy have been made on both sides. The Bank of Canada has estimated a projected loss of 60,000 jobs while others predict a boost to the economy with more people having access to disposable income.

The actual outcome remains to be seen yet the uncertainty has triggered some employers to examine the bottom line closely for cost savings. With the perceived need to curb costs, bonus pay can shine out as the low-hanging fruit. Some employers could eliminate it together. If the amount is large enough, your employer might even announce retroactive elimination of bonus pay before it becomes payable to you.

Such unilateral actions can leave employees feeling short-changed. Can your employer do this? How reasonably can you rely on bonus pay “promises” made to you?

Current Status of Bonus Pay Case Law

Canadian laws generally favour employees’ non-discretionary bonus pay which is based on a predetermined objective or calculation. Throughout your employment, the law upholds your contractual right to this type of bonus pay.

When your employer fails to pay out a predetermined bonus, the courts will establish whether they have breached your contract and substantially altered the terms of your agreement. The latter constitute grounds for constructive dismissal.

Under normal circumstances, if you resign from your post, you are ineligible for termination pay. However, constructive dismissal cases substantially alter that outcome. It puts your employer back on the hook for termination pay and any other contractual promises they made to you, including bonus pay.

Bonus Pay Withheld during Employment

Is this a Breach of Contract or a Constructive Dismissal? In the case of Chapman v. GPM Investment, Mr. Chapman was CEO of GPM Investment Management for 9 years. As part of his remuneration, he was eligible for a bonus pay of 10% of the company’s pre-tax profits. In 2011, his employer informed him that the calculation of profits would not include proceeds from a one-time real estate sale. And with it, they withheld a bonus payment of approximately $300,000.

Mr. Chapman quit his job and proceeded with a constructive dismissal claim. While the court recognized a fundamental breach of his employment agreement, they suggested the dispute arose over the interpretation of the bonus calculation and not a change of the contract. Consequently, the grounds for a constructive dismissal were weak. The court did not award him severance pay because he quit his position. But he was still awarded damages for breach of contract limited to his withheld bonus pay.

Bonus Pay and Constructive Dismissal

In a contrasting case, Prion v. Dominion Masonry, Mr. Prion was a foreman with Dominion Masonry for 19 years. When his employer unilaterally halted his pre-agreed bonus payment, he quit and claimed constructive dismissal. He had relied on this bonus for several years and it formed a substantial portion of his remuneration.

His employer did not dispute the facts. Rather, they cited tough economic times as their bonafide reason for withholding the bonus. The court sided with Mr. Prion stating his compensation had been substantially altered. This employer had breached a fundamental term of his contract. This satisfied the requirements for constructive dismissal.

Bonus Pay – Active Employment Clause

When employees are terminated, they are entitled to reasonable notice based on several factors. Employers must include the total remuneration the employee expected to receive in the calculation and not just the base pay.

This was illustrated in the case of Paquette v. TeraGo Networks Inc. The court dealt with a type of dispute common with bonus pay. The situation involved a contractual requirement for employees to be “actively employed on the date of the bonus payout”.

Trevor Paquette had been a Lead Systems Architect for 14 years until he was terminated from his employment. At trial, he was granted 17 months of termination pay. They unfortunately excluded the bonus pay from his award. Following an appeal, the court disregarded the “active employment” provision in the agreement because the bonus pay would have been effective, but for the termination.

Bonus Pay denied with Severance

Around the same time, the courts heard another similar case, Lin v. Ontario Teachers’ Pension Plan. Here, Mr. Lin was an investment professional eligible for two types of bonus pay from his employer. When they terminated his employment after 8 years, his employer refused to pay the bonus, citing the “active employment” clause in his contract. The court rendered this provision unenforceable.

Consequently, these two decisions now constitute the general legal standard for bonus pay entitlement in such situations.

When Courts Agree with Employers

While courts generally side with employees, there are exceptions.  The case of Kielb v. National Monetary Mart Company clearly demonstrated this.

Mr. Kielb, a lawyer, was employed for 18 months when his employer terminated him. His employment contract included a discretionary bonus pay. It expressly stated the bonus pay would not accrue over time. It also included specific examples of when the payout could occur. Not surprisingly, Mr. Kielb felt entitled to the bonus payments as part of his severance package.

To resolve this, the court examined how the contract was drawn up. Mr. Kielb, a lawyer who was familiar with contract negotiations, had vetted the contract extensively. He was intimate with the terms limiting his bonus payout. Nevertheless, he had agreed to them. Additionally, there was no public policy reason to disregard the verbiage of the contract. The court ruled in favour of the employer.

Bonus Pay – Consulting with a Lawyer

If you are employed without a written agreement, the law will uphold your right to receive earned income through bonus pay. The law presumes, by default, that you are eligible for your determined bonus, leaving your employer to prove otherwise.

If you are commencing a new employment relationship and a bonus is part of your remuneration package, then it is always a good idea to get this contract reviewed by an employment lawyer before you sign it. This is especially important if your contract includes terms that limit the payout.  We can inject clarity and fairness into the process, ensuring you do not face the same uncertainty as employees described in the case law examples above.


Lecker & Associates is a team of Toronto employment lawyers with over 35 years of experience. We exclusively represent employees. Wrongful and Constructive Dismissal cases remain a cornerstone of our practice. If you enjoyed this blog please consider sharing it.

Testimonials from Employees Like You

Posted on Google Google
Kelsie Rodden profile picture
Kelsie Rodden
2026-11-13
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I highly recommend Nathan. He was professional, knowledgeable, approachable and incredibly supportive throughout the entire process. He took the time to explain things clearly, answer my questions and ensure I felt informed and confident every step of the way. His guidance, patience and genuine compassion made a difficult process much easier to navigate. I truly appreciated his dedication and advocacy. It’s clear that he genuinely cares about his clients and the service he provides. I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend him to anyone looking for knowledgeable and supportive legal representation.
Posted on Google Google
Marni Sussman profile picture
Marni Sussman
2026-11-13
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I cannot recommend Lecker & Associates highly enough. I had the pleasure of dealing with Jon, who was absolutely exceptional. The staff is general were incredibly kind, professional, compassionate, and understanding throughout my interactions with them. What truly stood out was the genuine care, patience, and respect they demonstrated. They made me feel heard, supported, and comfortable, which makes an enormous difference when navigating what can often be a stressful and overwhelming legal situation. It is refreshing to encounter professionals who combine such a high level of professionalism and knowledge with genuine compassion and humanity. Bram and Jon went above and beyond in the way they treated me, and I am sincerely grateful for their kindness. I would wholeheartedly recommend Lecker & Associates to anyone looking for a legal team that treats people with dignity, respect, and compassion. An outstanding experience from start to finish!
Posted on Google Google
Drew Lashan profile picture
Drew Lashan
2026-11-13
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Want to personally thankMatthew and Eslita and Lecker and Associates who listened to my concerns and hep me find a resolution that I was happy with in a timely matter. Thank you again Matthew and Eslita!
Posted on Google Google
Joanne Bissonnette profile picture
Joanne Bissonnette
2026-11-12
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Joanne Bissonnette 25 September 2026 Awesome Team ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ "Thank you so much to Soniya Ponniah and Ashley Hussey at Lecker & Associates. You provided wonderful support, guidance, and clear communication throughout this employment law matter. Your exceptional legal counsel and strategic management led directly to a successful and highly agreeable resolution. I highly recommend your legal services. Thank you again!"
Posted on Google Google
cj ** profile picture
cj **
2026-11-09
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
It was a great experience for their service back in 2017. I had never used legal service for employment issues before in my life. I gave it a try and I found it very satisfied. You never know it until you try, They charged fee appropriately without more than they needed. Thank you Lecker!
Posted on Google Google
Eric Bibeau profile picture
Eric Bibeau
2026-11-03
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I can’t say enough good things about Lecker & Associates. From the first conversation, Matthew Fisher was clear, honest and strategic. He explained my options in plain language, set realistic expectations, and guided me to an outcome I’m very happy with. I always felt he was on my side and that my interests came first. Eslita Ramkishun was outstanding throughout. She was organized, quick to respond, and walked me through every document and next step, which made a stressful process feel manageable. What stood out most was how thoughtful and caring the whole team was. They treated me like a person, not a file. If you need a firm that combines sharp legal guidance with real compassion, I highly recommend Matthew, Eslita and the team at Lecker & Associates. — Eric Bibeau
Posted on Google Google
Gaz Kondaj profile picture
Gaz Kondaj
2026-10-29
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I cannot speak highly enough of Lecker & Associates and the exceptional legal representation and support I received from Kimberley, Ian, and Tina. From the very beginning, Kimberley demonstrated an outstanding level of professionalism, legal expertise, and strategic thinking. Her confidence, attention to detail, and thorough understanding of the legal process were instrumental in guiding the team toward a remarkable victory. Her ability to navigate complex challenges while remaining focused, composed, and determined truly sets her apart. Ian and Tina were equally exceptional, providing invaluable support, clear communication, and dedication throughout the entire process. Together, they demonstrated what a strong, knowledgeable, and committed legal team can accomplish. What impressed me most was not only the successful outcome, but also the integrity, professionalism, and genuine commitment they demonstrated every step of the way. It was reassuring to know that my matter was in such capable hands. A special thank you to Kimberley for her exceptional leadership, expertise, and determination in achieving such a fantastic result. I wholeheartedly recommend Lecker & Associates to anyone seeking outstanding legal representation. An exceptional team that delivers results and truly earns your trust!
Posted on Google Google
Jose Duran profile picture
Jose Duran
2026-10-18
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
This is the second time I have turned to Lecker & Associates for assistance with a work-related legal matter, and once again, the experience has exceeded my expectations. Counsel Jordan Reiner provided exceptional support throughout the process, demonstrating a thorough and thoughtful assessment of my situation, sound guidance grounded in experience, and a genuinely client-centered approach. He took the time to understand the circumstances, clearly explained my options, and provided the professional guidance and reassurance needed to navigate the matter with confidence. Thanks to his expertise, diligence, and commitment to achieving the best possible outcome, my legal matter was resolved successfully. It is reassuring to know that I can rely on a firm that combines legal expertise with a genuine commitment to its clients. I highly recommend Counsel Jordan Reiner and Lecker & Associates to anyone seeking knowledgeable, professional, and results-oriented legal representation, particularly in employment-related matters. Their consistent quality of service is the reason I have returned to the firm, and I would not hesitate to seek their assistance again.
Posted on Google Google
Barbara M. profile picture
Barbara M.
2026-10-09
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I had a great experience and outcome with the help of Nathan Whitteningham-Paralegal. He was professional and knowledgeable. He was always available to answer my many questions, explained my rights, and outlined the best approach to handle my situation with confidence. Though it felt like an eternity, Nathan was able to wrap up matters in quick order. I highly recommend his services.
Posted on Google Google
Yashraj Gandhi profile picture
Yashraj Gandhi
2026-10-08
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I had an excellent experience working with Jordan Reiner and Ashley Hussey on my case. They were professional, knowledgeable, responsive, and genuinely supportive throughout the process. I truly appreciate their dedication and the quality of service they provided. Highly recommended!

Breathe Easy, We’ve Got This

Reputation Matters